Paternity lawsuit - Best lawyers

A paternity suit is one of the most sensitive, complex, and significant proceedings in the Israeli legal world. It is a process that touches the deepest chords of the soul – identity, belonging, parental responsibility, and a child's basic right to know who their father is. Beyond the emotional and personal aspect, a paternity suit carries with it weighty economic and legal consequences, ranging from the obligation to pay child support to inheritance rights, civil status, and visitation arrangements.

In the State of Israel, due to the unique combination of civil law and religious law, a paternity suit is not limited to a simple laboratory test. It is a legal maze requiring exceptional expertise, social sensitivity, and a deep understanding of family law and children's rights. On this page, we will dive deep into the world of paternity suits, break down the stages, examine the Halachic (Jewish legal) obstacles, and understand how to act correctly to protect the rights of both the child and the parents.

What is a Paternity Suit and What is its Legal Purpose?

A paternity suit is a legal proceeding designed to officially and bindingly determine the identity of the child's father. In Israel, the authority to discuss these claims is uniquely given to the Family Court. Although in divorce matters there is parallel authority with the Religious Courts, in the matter of determining paternity, the legislator preferred the civil instance to ensure uniformity and protection of the child's fundamental rights.

The goals of such a claim can be varied and change according to the identity of the filer:

Ensuring the Child's Rights to Child Support and Sustenance

The most common goal is charging the father with child support payments. Without official recognition of paternity, a man cannot be obligated to bear the economic burden of raising the child. A declaratory judgment declaring paternity is the "key" to opening a child support file.

Realizing Inheritance Rights and Allowances

A child who is not registered as their father's son may lose their right to inheritance by law if the father dies without a will. Likewise, recognition of paternity allows for the receipt of survivors' benefits from the National Insurance Institute and other social rights due to the child by virtue of their father.

Regulating Personal Status and Identity

The right to know one's origin is a constitutional right. Knowing the father's identity allows the child to build their self-identity, know their family history, and receive critical genetic medical information to prevent hereditary diseases.

Realizing the Father's Parental Rights

Often, it is the father who files the claim (a claim for a declaration of paternity). He asks to be recognized as a parent so that he can be involved in his child's life, receive visitation arrangements, and realize his duties and rights as a father.

The Normative Framework: The Genetic Information Law

The Genetic Information Law, 5761-2000, is the legal basis for all modern paternity suits in Israel. The law established a revolution in the way courts treat biological evidence.

Key Principles of the Law

1. Prohibition on private testing: The law prohibits laboratories in Israel from performing a paternity test without a court order. Anyone performing such a test "under the radar" may face criminal sanctions, and the results will not be admissible in court.
2. The right to genetic privacy: Genetic information is considered one of the most sensitive types of information. Therefore, the court must balance the need to discover the truth with the infringement on the privacy of the examinees.
3. Priority of the child's best interest: This is the supreme principle. The law states that if there is a probability that the test will cause harm to the child, the court may (and indeed must) refuse to order it.

The Biggest Obstacle: Fear of Mamzerut (Bastardy)

In Israel, civil law takes into account personal (religious) law. The most complex issue in paternity suits is the Halachic stain of "Mamzerut".

What is Mamzerut and What are its Consequences?

According to Jewish Halacha, a child born to a married woman as a result of a relationship with a man who is not her husband is considered a Mamzer. A Mamzer is limited in their ability to marry other Jews "in the congregation of the Lord" (except for other Mamzers or converts). This is a severe social and legal stigma that passes from generation to generation.

The Role of the State and the Attorney General

In every paternity suit where the mother was married to another at the time of the pregnancy (or within 300 days from the day of divorce), the court will turn to receive an opinion from the President of the Great Rabbinical Court. The State, through the State Attorney's Office, will intervene in the proceeding to prevent harm to the child.

Socio-Paternity vs. Biology

In cases where there is a fear of Mamzerut, the Israeli court will almost always choose the "child's welfare" over the "biological truth". It may reject the claim outright so as not to harm the child's legitimacy. In such cases, the child will continue to be legally considered the husband's son (by virtue of the Halachic presumption "most acts of intercourse follow the husband"), or will remain without a registered father, but a test proving the father is a third party will not be performed.

The Claim Process: Step by Step

Managing a paternity suit requires deep familiarity with the special procedures in the Family Court.

Filing the Statement of Claim and Preliminary Evidence

The claim begins with filing a detailed statement of claim. The plaintiff must show "prima facie evidence" of the existence of a connection. One cannot simply "drop" a lawsuit on a person without any basis. Possible evidence:

• WhatsApp correspondence or emails indicating an intimate relationship.
• Shared photos.
• Testimonies of friends or family members who knew the couple.
• Location data (in exceptional cases) or proof of spending time together at times relevant to conception.

Preliminary Hearing and Respondents' Position

The court summons the parties. At the same time, the State Attorney's Office (representing the State) submits its position. If it involves a single couple (bachelors/long-time divorcees), the process is usually simpler and faster.

Appointment of a Guardian ad litem for the Child

Since the child is the center of the proceeding but cannot represent themselves, the court often appoints a lawyer from Legal Aid for them. The role of the Guardian ad litem is to examine the child's best interest strictly apart from the wars between the parents. They will visit the home, speak with the parents, and submit a recommendation to the court on whether to approve the genetic test.

Issuing the Order for Tissue Typing

If the court is convinced that the test will not harm the child, it issues a formal order. The order is directed to one of the four authorized laboratories in Israel (Sheba, Hadassah, Beilinson, or Rambam).

Tissue Testing: Technology and Execution

Modern paternity testing is based on comparing DNA segments (nucleic acid) between the alleged father and the child.

How is the test performed?

The test today is very simple and non-invasive. Usually, it involves a cheek swab (saliva) or a simple blood test. Samples are taken from the father, the mother, and the child. The mother's presence is important to isolate the genetic material the child received from her, thereby making it easier to identify the material received from the father.

The Test's Level of Accuracy

Tissue typing is considered the "queen" of evidence in modern law. The accuracy level stands at over 99.9%. If the result is negative, it is absolute (100% not the father). If it is positive, the probability that it is another person is negligible.

Genetic Confidentiality

The test results are sent directly from the laboratory to the court in a sealed envelope. The parties receive the result only after the court has reviewed it. The genetic information is not used for any other purpose (such as diagnosing diseases) but solely for clarifying paternity.

Refusal to Undergo a Paternity Test: What are the Consequences?

One of the common questions is: "What if the man refuses to be tested?". In the past, such refusal could stall the proceeding for years. Today, Israeli law has created a strong deterrent solution.

Presumption of Paternity by Virtue of Refusal

Section 28H of the Genetic Information Law states that if a person refuses to undergo a test despite a court order, the court is entitled to deduce from his refusal that he is indeed the father. The logic is simple: a person who truly believes he is not the father would rush to be tested to remove the cloud hanging over him. Refusal is perceived as an attempt to hide the truth.

Additional sanctions on refusers:

• The court may impose on a refuser:
• Daily fines for contempt of court.
• Charging heavy legal expenses.
• Setting temporary child support even before the final judgment, based on existing evidence and the refusal.

Special Types of Paternity Suits

Paternity Suit After the Father's Death

When the alleged father has passed away, the need for recognition becomes urgent for inheritance purposes. In such a case, a test can be performed in indirect ways:

• Use of DNA samples kept in hospitals (if blood tests were performed on the deceased).
• Testing first-degree relatives (brothers of the deceased or his parents). This test is statistically more complex and requires a genetics expert to assess the probability of a family connection.
• Opening a grave: This is an extreme and very rare step in Israel, which the court will approve only in exceptional cases within exceptions, due to respect for the dead.

Paternity Suit for a Non-Resident

When the father is abroad, the proceeding is conducted with the help of international cooperation. Samples are taken at the Israeli consulate in the destination country and sent to a laboratory in Israel. The representing lawyer needs to be familiar with the Hague Conventions and international registration procedures.

Paternity Suit in Surrogacy or Sperm Donation Cases

Here the complexity is legal-contractual. Although there is a biological father, there may be another intended father. In cases of surrogacy abroad, the State requires a paternity test upon landing in Israel to verify genetic affinity as a condition for granting Israeli citizenship to the child.

The Economic Aspect: Retroactive Child Support

After a declaratory judgment declaring paternity is given, the question of child support arises.

Can One Claim Child Support Retroactively?

As a rule, child support is awarded from the day the claim is filed. However, in certain circumstances, the court may award retroactive child support for the period preceding the claim, especially if it is proven that the father knew of the child's existence and deliberately evaded responsibility. These are sums that can accumulate to hundreds of thousands of shekels.

Inheritance Rights

The moment a declaratory judgment is given, the child becomes a legal heir according to the Inheritance Law. Their status is equal to all the father's other children, even if born out of wedlock.

Paternity Suit and Visitation Arrangements (Stay)

Recognition of paternity is a double-edged sword for some mothers. While they receive child support, they are also obligated to allow the father to be part of the child's life.

The Father's Right to a Relationship with His Son

A father who has been officially recognized is entitled to file a claim for visitation arrangements. The State encourages a relationship with both parents as part of the child's best interest. In cases of long disconnection, the relationship will be renewed gradually through a "contact center" accompanied by social workers, until trust is built between the child and the father.

Joint Custody

In the modern era, claims for joint custody are increasing even among parents who never lived together. A father who has proved paternity can demand full parental responsibility, a matter which may also affect the amount of child support he will pay.

The Importance of Professional Accompaniment by an Expert Lawyer

A paternity suit is not a "technical form". It is a legal strategy. A small mistake in reporting or a lack of understanding of the implications of Mamzerut can cause irreversible damage to the child. An expert lawyer in family law (in the context of paternity suits) will perform for you:

• Feasibility check: Is it worth filing the claim now at all?
• Managing the Halachic risk: How to phrase things so that the court does not reject the claim due to fear of Mamzerut.
• Representation vis-à-vis the Guardian ad litem: Ensuring that the expert's recommendation serves your interest.

Planning the Next Step the Day After Receiving DNA Results

On the LawReviews website, you can find real and verified reviews of leading lawyers in the field of family law. Do not rely on luck in such a fateful matter – choose a professional who has proven themselves with other clients. The wisdom of the crowd is your best tool to ensure you are in good and professional hands.

Points for Thought and Summary

A paternity suit is a journey to discover the truth, but this truth carries heavy responsibility. Before starting the process, it is important to weigh the long-term consequences:

• The emotional connection: How will the discovery affect the child at school and in society?
• Economic stability: Is the claim truly intended for the child's benefit or as a tool to bash the other side?
• The Halachic future: Are we endangering the child's ability to marry in the future?

In the State of Israel, where religion and state are intertwined, only professional accompaniment by an experienced lawyer can ensure that you pass this procedure with minimum damage and maximum rights. The LawReviews site is here to help you find the right expert, based on the experience of others. Information is your power – use it wisely.

About LawReviews

The LawReviews Platform was established to provide the public with up-to-date and reliable information on lawyers in Israel and at the same time allow lawyers to manage and strengthen their presence on the internet. The uniqueness of the site lies in being a platform that allows the public to receive information about hundreds of law firms based on up-to-date reviews published by their clients only. Besides authentic reviews, you can also find on the page a list of Family Law Attorneys specializing in paternity suits. So you can find the best lawyer for you easily and quickly.